The Cayman Drama Society is preparing to bring the award-winning musical ‘In the Heights’ to the Prospect Playhouse stage.
The production, which runs from 28 May to 14 June, promises a vibrant mix of music, dance and storytelling inspired by the Latino community of Washington Heights, New York.

Ahead of opening night, co-directors Cynthia Powell and Judith Nicholls spoke to Cayman Independent about the show’s Caribbean connections, the challenges of staging such an ambitious production, and why they believe audiences will leave both entertained and inspired.
For those not familiar, can you tell us a bit about In the Heights?
Cynthia Powell: In the Heights is a high-energy, heartfelt musical, created by Lin-Manuel Miranda and first staged in 2005, that tells the story of a vibrant Latino community in Washington Heights, New York.
Through music, dance, and powerful storytelling, it explores themes of family, identity, dreams, culture and what it truly means to call a place ‘home’.
It blends hip hop, salsa, merengue and musical theatre into a production that is both emotionally moving and incredibly fun.
What made you choose this particular musical?
Judith Nicholls: There is a large Latin American community in Cayman, and many Caymanians also have Latin American heritage.
I believe it’s important that the work presented on stage reflects and resonates with the community we live in and serve.
This story also speaks strongly to Cayman and to Caribbean communities as a whole, exploring the balance between preserving culture, identity and a sense of home, while also embracing progress, development and modernisation.
In a true full-circle moment, In the Heights was the very first musical I ever saw on Broadway back in 2009, so having the opportunity to bring it to the Cayman stage feels incredibly special and meaningful.
The music is vibrant and energetic, blending hip-hop with Latin styles such as bachata, merengue and salsa.
It’s a production filled with heart, passion and energy, and I believe audiences will leave feeling both entertained and inspired.
Can you tell me a bit about how you’ve approached it?

JN: Preparation is always key in the process. We spent a great deal of time listening to the music, analysing the script and mapping out the entire production – researching the inspiration behind the work itself, the community of Washington Heights, the feel and energy of each scene, and considering what each character would need and how they would respond.
The next step was assembling the creative team, which I believe is one of the most important elements of any production.
I feel incredibly fortunate to have Cyn co-directing alongside me, as our creative visions and attention to detail complement each other so well.
We also had the amazing Carlha Peña as choreographer, who was instrumental in helping bring the entire vision to life.
What have rehearsals been like?
JN: Our rehearsal schedule was rigorous from the outset. We began rehearsals in January, meeting three days a week.
The musical – in true Lin-Manuel Miranda style – is complex, energetic, and demands a high level of coordination, communication, and stamina.
Over time, the cast has truly become like a family, and that sense of camaraderie and community is what creates the vibrant energy audiences see on stage.
How big is the cast?
CP: We have a wonderfully talented cast of approximately 22 performers, and it is a great mix of familiar Cayman Drama Society faces alongside many exciting newcomers.
One of the most rewarding parts of this production has been seeing experienced performers mentoring and encouraging others.
How do you feel about the upcoming run?
JN: It would be dishonest to say we aren’t nervous. With a production of this scale, there are so many moving parts that need to come together seamlessly, and naturally that comes with a certain level of anxiety.
At the same time, we are incredibly excited. This is a truly unique and special production – one that everyone involved, from the cast to the creative team and crew, has poured their heart and soul into.
We genuinely cannot wait to share it with the people of Cayman and to finally see audiences experience all the passion, energy and love that have gone into this production.
During the run, In the Heights will play on Thursday, Friday, Saturday evenings from 7:30pm and Sunday matinee from 3pm. Tickets can be booked here.



