The government can count how many people receive social assistance but cannot yet show whether its programmes are improving lives, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has heard.
Nellie Pouchie, chief officer at the Ministry of Social Development and Innovation, told members on 8 September that the ministry measures what it delivers, rather than outcomes.
Pouchie was giving evidence during the hearings examining hundreds of outstanding recommendations from the Office of the Auditor General (OAG) and PAC.
As of 15 March, the ministry had 22 outstanding recommendations, according to the OAG report discussed by the committee.
Of those, 14 had been completed, seven were in progress and one had not been implemented.
Many of the recommendations related to social assistance programmes and dated back to 2015.
They covered areas including performance measurement, monitoring, reporting, strategy and policy development.
The committee examined a recommendation that the government measure and monitor the performance of social assistance programmes and regularly report on the results achieved.
Pouchie said the ministry can track the number of families, households and people receiving services, as well as the types of assistance provided.
“Currently, the budget documents will speak to what outputs the department is supposed to adhere to or to be able to deliver in that period,” she said.
However, the ministry has not yet developed the same level of measurement for what happens after assistance is provided, saying: “that is something that would be work in progress”.
“We want to get to, ‘are these programmes making a difference in the way that we want to see?’,” she said.
Pouchie said measuring outcomes would require a broader system and more resources.
“Outcome based is a much broader piece of work, much bigger, that will involve a lot more resources as well,” she said.
The hearing also raised questions about a separate recommendation calling for a coordinated social assistance strategy.
Pouchie said the ministry does not have a standalone strategy because it considers the Financial Assistance Act 2022 to fulfil the recommendation. The law came into force in October 2024.
“We’ve outlined why we think it meets it,” Pouchie said. “And then once the OAG is in receipt of this information, they will be able to advise if that from their opinion meets their recommendation.”
The information had not yet been provided to the OAG when the hearing took place.
Deputy Governor Gloria McField-Nixon had earlier told the committee that the government considered the 2015 social assistance recommendations completed.
She said the Financial Assistance Act “now provides the coordinated social assistance strategy the OAG once found missing”.



