A Cayman Islands passport is not sufficient proof to establish Caymanian status and obtain a national ID card, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) heard on Tuesday, 8 September.
Applicants for the My eID card, the government’s official photo identification card, who were born after March 1977 must provide documentation to establish they are Caymanian.
The committee heard this must take the form of an acknowledgement letter, confirmation letter or status grant verified through Workforce Opportunities and Residency Cayman (WORC).
Deputy chief officer Charles Brown, who leads the My eID project at the Ministry of Social Development and Innovation, explained to the committee that he is bound by the Immigration (Transition) Act as the only law with the power to determine who is Caymanian.
The process happens one applicant at a time, he explained, relying on verification through WORC, rather than on the documents provided by the applicant.
Asked by MP Kenneth Bryan what happens to an applicant who holds a Cayman Islands passport but does not possess one of the three documents outlined, Brown said the card would be issued with the status field left blank.
“If you remain unacknowledged, you essentially are one of the group of ‘the believed to be Caymanians’, if that’s a term,” Brown said. “It would print as ‘dash dash dash’, not as Caymanian.”
The disclosure came during two days of hearings called to examine why 249 recommendations from the Office of the Auditor General and previous committees remained unimplemented.
The identity card was not on the agenda but arose after MP Christopher Saunders raised the question.
The committee heard that, as of August, 2,109 Caymanians and permanent residents had successfully established a My eID card, representing about 2% of the population.
The ministry was not able to verify during the meeting how many of the cardholders were Caymanians.
Saunders questioned why the ID database could not simply be linked to the elections database to identify who is already Caymanian, sparing people the need to produce a letter of acknowledgement.
“I hate the fact that Caymanians have to go immigration and get a letter of acknowledgement. That drives me crazy. I’ve never gotten one. My kids have never gotten one and I refuse to get one,” he said.
Chief officer Nellie Pouchie said the single source of proof sits with WORC.
Later, during MP Bryan’s questions on the topic, Saunders could be heard in the background, saying he intended to raise the issue in parliament, scheduled to meet next on 30 September.
Brown added that My eID accepts a voter’s ID as proof of identity but not of status.
The distinction matters because, as he explained, the electoral register lists people entitled to vote rather than people who are Caymanian, and not every Caymanian appears on the register.



